The records consist of three items and one volume. The first item is "Minutes of Ch[urch] meeting for formation of the Church in Parma" (1819); the second item is a confession from a member (1830); the third item is a church membership list compiled in 1867, covering the years 1819-1867. The volume is titled "The Sunday School Receiving Book. Congregational S.S. West Greece." and is a student record (1846).

One volume containing original members' names and a list of persons added subsequently (1841-1843); a membership list for Class No. 2 (organized at North Greece); quarterly conference meeting minutes (1841-1881); baptisms (1843, 1848); marriages (1842); and a list of collections (1843-1844)

The parish register includes records of baptisms (1848-1860); marriage records (1849-1860); and death records (1849-1860).