One volume contains records of the Marcellus First Church, including lists of members, minutes of church meetings 1833-1872, baptismal records and contributions to the American Bible Society. One volume of records contains annual meeting minutes of the trustees of the Eastern Religious Society (1844-1935) and pew rental lists.

One volume contains meeting minutes, membership lists, and birth records, 1801-1843. One volume contains records for 1801-1918 including register (1853-1905), deaths and funerals, church members, baptisms, marriages and non-resident members, and newspaper articles on the centennial history of the church. One volume contains session meeting minutes for 1854-1917.